The charity Buglife launched ‘Cardiff Urban Buzz’ at the
Chapter Arts Centre on 24 Nov 2015. Cardiff is one of eight cities across the
UK that will receive funding over a total of three years (18 months each) within
the Urban Buzz project, which aims to benefit both pollinators and people.
Funded by a Biffa Award (from landfill tax), the Heritage Lottery Fund, the Garfield
Weston Foundation and other organisations, depending on location, Urban Buzz
will create pollinator habitats, such as wildflower meadows, and engage with a
diverse range of people, groups and organisations. The project will provide
volunteers with training and experience in the field of habitat creation,
habitat assessment, and conservation practice.
Clare Dunham of Buglife welcomed us all to the launch event.
She put the initiative into context, for example, its contribution to the Welsh
Assembly Government’s Action Plan for Pollinators.
Urban Buzz is one of two projects involving Buglife that aim
to benefit pollinating insects (mainly bees, but also other invertebrates such
as butterflies, moths and beetles). The other project is B-lines, in which a
network of wildflower-rich grassland corridors is being established through the
countryside. This is a good example of landscape-scale conservation (see link
below), and provides the ecological corridors linking biodiversity that are
vital as habitats increasingly fragment and the climate changes. Such a system
of B-lines is being planned for South Wales, along the lines of B-lines already
created in the West of England as a result of a collaboration between Buglife
and Avon Wildlife Trust.
At the Urban Buzz launch, Councillor Bob Derbyshire (Rumney,
Cardiff) outlined the importance to Cardiff of the project, which will
establish partnerships to enhance parks and gardens for wildlife in the city.
Michelle Bales of Buglife then reminded us of the importance
of pollinators and provided more detail about Cardiff Urban Buzz. Urban areas provide
an important refuge for pollinators, particularly bees, which are declining in
the countryside due to loss of natural habitats, intensive farming practices and
the use of pesticides. The decline in the total number and the number of
species of bumblebees, honeybees and other pollinators are genuinely alarming,
especially given that they are vital for the pollination of many food crops and
a large amount of our native flora. One in every three mouthfuls of food,
accordingly to statistics presented here, contains a food crop pollinated by insects.
In Cardiff, a local steering group will direct the Cardiff
Urban Buzz actions; the group will include Buglife, Cardiff Council, the local Wildlife
Trust, the National Museum Wales in Cardiff, Keep Wales Tidy and a range of
local community groups. The project aims to create habitats for pollinators in
partnership with local organisations. The overall goal is to create 100 habitat
areas in the eight cities (25 ha per city), on both the small and large scale.
This will include wildflower meadows, green walls, bee hotels, and other appropriate
foraging and nesting sites for pollinator species. Engaging with a diverse
range of people and organisations, to raise awareness and to get as many
volunteers on board as possible, is an essential part of the project.
Volunteers will be able to learn new practical skills through training
workshops in habitat creation, habitat assessment, identification and monitoring.
The project will provide tools and resources for habitat creation, and the
capacity that will enable these local initiatives to carry on after the 18
months of the Cardiff Urban Buzz project.
Michelle pointed us in the direction of the project website –
www.buglife.org.uk/urban-buzz/cardiff
- where people can suggest sites for pollinator habitat creation or
enhancement. These sites already include parks, Cathays Cemetery, river and
lakeside areas, and allotments. Further along the line, there will be a public
voting system to prioritise lines of action. This all helps create the sense of
ownership necessary for the longevity of the project actions.
The next stage will be volunteer recruitment and the
selection of sites, so visit the website or contact Michelle Bales (michelle.bales@buglife.org.uk)
if you are interested or know a good as yet unsuggested site.
Julie Hughes, representing the Heritage Lottery Fund, gave
the final short presentation. In south Wales, the Heritage Lottery Fund has
funded numerous natural heritage projects, including two high profile projects:
the Living Levels to promote conservation in the Gwent Levels and the Forgotten
Landscape Partnership Project focused on the Blaenavon World Heritage Site (the
wildlife value of coal spoil tips and brownfield sites are now starting to be
recognised). The selection criteria focuses on what people consider important,
and what will provide benefits to both nature and people. So far the Cardiff-based
Heritage Lottery Fund Wales has distributed around £320 million to around 2,300
projects of widely-ranging sizes in Wales.
Selected previous posts on pollinators on this blog:
http://sfnottingham.blogspot.co.uk/2014/01/nectar-point-networks.html
http://sfnottingham.blogspot.co.uk/2014/03/nectar-point-networks-2.html
A news story I did on the ‘The Future of Landscape-scale
Conservation in Europe’ meeting in Bristol (4-5 March 2015) for the EC LIFE
Programme website:
http://ec.europa.eu/environment/life/news/newsarchive2015/march/index.htm#landscape-scale
See also:
http://www.buglife.org.uk
http://www.hlf.org.uk
http://bumblebeeconservation.org
In a previous post (15 Jan 2014), I introduced the concept
of a Nectar Point Network (NPN). The driving force for the establishment of NPN
hubs in the Cardiff area is Professor Denis Bellamy, who is the Chairman of the
Conservation Management System Consortium (CMSC) and a former head of the
Zoology Department at University College Cardiff. He has put together an informative
website on NPNs (see link below). The Cardiff NPN is taking shape through a ‘bottom
up’ approach. In an email in February, Prof Bellamy explained that, “it is
envisaged that each hub organises itself as a self-sustaining community nectar
point with its own action plan and local funding”.
The Nightingale Community Garden in Dinas Powys was
established last year, a process I outlined in a series of posts (see links
below). At the start of this year, I registered
the Community Garden as a potential Nectar Point Network hub. As a first step
into making this happen, I applied for and got an award (£100 of garden
vouchers) from Keep Wales Tidy’s Wild Weekend Voucher Application, which this
year aims to improve food sources for pollinators and is aimed at community
groups. One stipulation is that plants purchased should be on the Royal
Horticultural Society (RHS) Perfect for Pollinators Plant List.

I spent the voucher on two bee nesting boxes; five large
pots; four bags of peat-free organic compost; a bee-friendly Escallonia ‘Apple blossom’ bush; and packets
of nectar-rich plant seed, including lavender, foxglove, borage,
cornflower, marigold, marjoram and 'wild flower honey bee mix'. I intend to add a winter-flowering honeysuckle
at a later date, along with some surplus rosemary, primrose and heather from my garden. The idea is to establish a border of nectar-rich plants at one end of Nightingale
Community Garden, with five pots of bee-friendly flowers in other areas of the
garden. This will be our starting point, from which other activities will flow.

There are numerous nectar-rich plants that can be grown for
pollinating insects. The consensus is that variety is more important than focusing
on any one plant species. This is for several reasons. A range of different
species can be grown that produce nectar at different times of the year, for
instance, to feed pollinating insects active in different seasons. Furthermore,
different pollinators are adapted to different flower structures, for example,
long-faced bumblebees with long feeding parts (e.g. Bombus hortorum) are specialised to get the nectar from flowers with
long corolla, such as foxgloves. Another factor is flower colour, with
different pollinating insects homing in on different colours (e.g. Bombus
lapidarius has a fondness for yellow flowers); so the more colourful
the pollinator border the better!
A recent study, conducted by Mikhail Garbuzov and Francis Ratnieks
at the University of Sussex with 32 popular summer flowering plants over a
two-year period, identified which were the most attractive to insect
pollinators. Borage (Borago officinalis),
lavender (Lavandula) and marjoram (Origanum majorana) scored highly. However,
not all lavenders were attractive to bees, only the wild types, with
highly-bred ones such as those with novel colours not proving very attractive. Borage
flowers were the most attractive to honey bees. Perennial lamb’s ear (Stachys byzantina) was the most popular
plant with more unusual bees, such as the solitary wool-carder bee (Anthidium manicatum). The
authors concluded that choosing the plants you grow carefully can make a big
difference to pollinators. The least attractive plant in this study was the
widely-planted pelargonium.
A previous study, conducted at the University of Cambridge in
1999, of 24 plant species (not the same plants as in the Sussex study) also
revealed large differences in terms of insect pollinator visits. The most
visited plants by honey bees in this study were Malva moschata, Salvia
pratensis, Malva sylvestris, Scabiosa columbaria, Centaurea pratensis, Knautia arvensis, Trifolium repens, Salvia
verbenaca, Lythrum salicaria and Saponaria officinalis. The
bumblebee most recorded was Bombus
pascuorum, which preferred Trifolium
pratense, Salvia pratense, Trifolium repens, Laminium album and Stachys
sylvatica.
The references to both these papers are below. They
provide a good entry point into the scientific literature on this subject.
I will post more on NPNs and pollinating insects later in
the spring, along with an update on progress in the Nightingale Community
Garden as it enters its second year.
Nectar Point Network website:
https://www.sites.google.com/site/nectarpointnetwork/
Previous post on Nectar Point Networks:
http://sfnottingham.blogspot.co.uk/2014/01/nectar-point-networks.html
Previous posts on Nightingale Community Garden:
Sept 2013
http://sfnottingham.blogspot.co.uk/2013/09/creating-community-garden-10.html
June 2013
http://sfnottingham.blogspot.co.uk/2013/06/creating-community-garden-9.html
April 2013
http://sfnottingham.blogspot.co.uk/2013/04/creating-community-garden-8.html
March 2013
http://sfnottingham.blogspot.co.uk/2013/03/creating-community-garden-7.html
Feb 2013
http://sfnottingham.blogspot.co.uk/2013/02/creating-community-garden-6.html
Jan 2013
http://sfnottingham.blogspot.co.uk/2013/01/creating-community-garden-5.html
Oct 2012
http://sfnottingham.blogspot.co.uk/2012/10/creating-community-garden-4.html
Aug 2012
http://sfnottingham.blogspot.co.uk/2012/08/creating-community-garden-3.html
Feb 2012
http://sfnottingham.blogspot.co.uk/2012/02/creating-community-garden-2.html
Jan 2012
http://sfnottingham.blogspot.com/2012/01/creating-community-garden.html
References:
Livio Comba, Sarah A. Corbet, Lynn Hunt & Ben Warren
(1999), Flowers, nectar and insect visits: Evaluating British plant species for
pollinator-friendly gardens’, Annals of Botany 83: 369-383. Online: http://aob.oxfordjournals.org/content/83/4/369.full.pdf
Mikhail Garbuzov & Francis L.W. Ratnieks (2013),
Quantifying variation among garden plants in attractiveness to bees and
other flower-visiting insects’,
Functional Ecology (Oct 2013): http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/1365-2435.12178/full
Most fruit and vegetable plants require pollination, yet the
honeybees, bumblebees, hoverflies and other insects that carry out the pollination are
having a tough time. Habitats are being degraded,
reducing the number of nectar-rich plants in built-up areas; while disease, varroa
mite and insecticides have taken their toll on honeybee numbers.
The situation can be improved by individuals planting
nectar-rich plant species for feeding insects on an ad hoc basis. However, an
initiative to improve insect pollination services through public participation
has just been launched: the Nectar Point Network.
A nectar point is a location that has been augmented with
plants that produce nectar for insects. It could be in a community garden, residential
garden, school grounds, park, roadside verge, or even a large window-box. A
nectar point network is a coordinated series of such nectar points in a given
area. The network rests on a group of local activists in a growers hub, such as
a community garden, who use their skills and resources to propagate nectar-rich
plants to supply to their neighbours.
The main considerations in establishing nectar points are to
select nectar-rich plants to grow in soil or containers, and to keep a record
of the outcomes of planting and any monitoring of pollinators that is done. There
is therefore an element of citizen science involved in nectar point networks,
with participants encouraged to learn about different pollinator species (e.g.,
bumblebees) and to communicate their
findings to other groups (e.g., via websites and blogs).
Networks of nectar points can be planned to create ecological corridors through built-up areas for pollinating insects, and to generally enhance local biodiversity and wildlife in gardens and streets. Networks can also, of course, encompass apiaries, and the strategic location of bee tubes or hotels for solitary bees species.
Here are some bee-friendly plants for gardens: heathers, rosemary,
dead nettles, pussy willow, thyme, cotoneaster, wallflower, sage, honeysuckle,
comfrey, cornflower, buddleia, delphinium, hollyhock, and lavender.
The Nectar Point Network website suggests several local actions for
groups. ‘Linking with Lavender’ is one example of a
neighbourhood growing scheme with the objective of establishing nectar-rich plants for pollinators in an urban setting. It relies on a local community garden acting
as a hub for propagating and distributing plants in pots to its
neighbours. The pots can be returned to
the hub annually or purchased. Costs
could be met by local sponsorship. The pots, containing lavender or any other
nectar-rich plants, can be used on patios or paved front garden.
A Welsh Government draft Action Plan for Pollinating Insects
was launched in July 2013 (see below), in recognition of the major economic importance of natural pollination services. Also, a new Welsh Government initiative
called Cynefin (meaning ‘habitat’) aims to help individuals and groups
throughout Wales mount community-led environmental action plans. Cynefin
Cardiff is already working with four community gardens in Cardiff with a view
to starting a city-wide Nectar Point Network.
This should be the first of a series of posts on Nectar
Point Networks on this blog, as I help get a network hub started here in Dinas
Powys. I will report on what is involved, and write more about schemes to
improve the pollination of fruit and vegetable plants, during the year.
Nectar Point Network website:
https://www.sites.google.com/site/nectarpointnetwork/home
Nightingale Community Garden, Dinas Powys:
http://sfnottingham.blogspot.co.uk/2013/09/creating-community-garden-10.html
Welsh Government Action Plan for Pollinators (links to draft
documents here):
http://wales.gov.uk/topics/environmentcountryside/consmanagement/conservationbiodiversity/action-plan-for-pollinators/?lang=en
Friends of the Earth ‘The Bee Cause’ campaign:
http://www.foe.co.uk/bees